Appendix 8: Civilian Casualties in Gt. Britain caused by enemy action during 1939–45
Some explanation is necessary to account for the difference between the two sets of figures in Table 3. The figures supplied by the Ministry of Home Security include civil defence personnel, but exclude the National Fire Service, the Police, H.M. Forces, the Home Guard, Observer Corps and men of the Merchant Navy. On the other hand, the Registrar-General’s statistics, while excluding H.M. Forces (except for women in the Forces up to mid-1941) do include seamen dying in Great Britain as a result of enemy action of any kind, and civilians killed at sea by enemy action.
The two sets of figures do not, therefore, cover precisely comparable groups of population. Moreover, neither is restricted to casualties caused directly by bombing. In the first place, the Home Security statistics do not include a include a proportion of the deaths of persons who were injured by enemy action and subsequently died. The Registrar-General’s returns do, assuming that death certification gives precedence to the initial injury, and insofar as death occurred before the end of the German war. Then again, the former includes civilians killed by cross-channel shelling, by machine-gunning from German aeroplanes, by exploding anti-aircraft shells and as a result of other defending action. But the Registrar-General’s figures are wider in scope, for they include in addition civilian casualties caused by sea-mines, crashed Allied aircraft, Army manoeuvres and battle exercises, train and vehicle accidents caused by enemy action and other deaths due to operations of war.
Another reason for the difference between the figures is that death registration could not be carried out until identification was completed. In many instances, bodies—and parts of bodies—were not recovered for a long time, and identification was delayed for weeks or months. Where no remains were found, it was necessary to establish the fact that the missing person had been on the spot at the time of the ‘incident’ before registration could be effected and satisfactory evidence produced. All this meant delays before death registrations were made. This factor applies particularly to the Scottish data which are tabulated only by date of registration.
The injury statistics in Tables 5 and 6 are only approximate estimates. They are likely to underestimate, rather than exaggerate,
the number of civilians injured by war operations in general and air bombardment in particular. The chief reason would appear to be that an unknown number of seriously injured people (and some whose injuries were first thought to be slight but later were found to be serious, and a large number of slightly injured people, never went to a hospital or first-aid post and were consequently omitted from official records. In addition, numbers of first-aid posts were bomb-ed and records destroyed, while in times of stress injuries were attended and not recorded. The distinction between seriously and slightly injured is somewhat thin, for the method of recording often varied from hospital to hospital, and by no means all hospital cases were, in reality, seriously injured. The figures must simply be accepted as showing the order of magnitude of casualty rates. Tables 5 and 6 exclude injuries to the Police, the National Fire Service, H.M. Forces and certain other categories.
Ministry of Home Security statistics, based chiefly on police notifications, give a total of 149,040 slightly injured civilians for the whole of Britain. This total is smaller than the figure of 165,743 compiled from first-aid post records, but the latter includes a proportion—estimated at one-fifth—who were sent on for hospital treatment. If the estimate of 149,040 is taken to represent the slightly injured, and the 85,504 hospital cases are added, a ratio of 3·9 injured persons to one killed is thus obtained.
The statistics of killed and injured (see Tables 3–6) when analysed separately for London show the following ratios:
Ratio of killed to all injured
|London region 1940–3 (piloted aircraft)||1 : 3·6|
|London region 1944–5 (flying-bombs and rockets)||1 : 7·0|
|Rest of Britain 1940–5||1 : 3·2|
|Scotland 1940–5||1 : 2·5|
A study by the Research and Experiments Department of the Ministry of Home Security of the data for a large number of towns during 1940–1 showed that the ratio lay fairly consistently between 1 : 3 and 1 : 4.
A statistical analysis, by the General Register Office, of the sex and age distribution of civilians injured by enemy action and admitted to emergency medical service hospitals was published in 1948.1 The following rations serve to show how the different forms of enemy action affected the injury rates for the sexes, for children and for adults under sixty-five and older people. The figures do not represent annual rates, but the relative incident of injuries resulting in hospital
admission among the six groups of the population can be compared by expressing each series of rates in terms of the corresponding rate for females aged fifteen to sixty-four taken as 100, namely:
|Period||Boys under 15||Girls under 15||Men aged 15–64||Women aged 15–64||Men 65 and over||Women 65 and over|
|1st January 1940 to 12th June 1944. Air raids||49||41||185||100||177||172|
|13th June to 31st August 1944. Chiefly flying-bombs||35||35||92||100||162||211|
|1st September 1944 to the end of the war. Flying-bombs and rockets.||56||61||83||100||106||139|
Number of civilians in Great Britain killed by enemy action 1939–45.
Compiled by Ministry of Home Security from police and medical reports2
Classified as due to operations of war by the Registrars-General3
England and Wales4
|Northern Ireland (1941)||967|
The comparatively low rates among children reflect the results of evacuation. During the period of aircraft bombing civilian men aged under sixty-five suffered nearly twice the rate experience by women of the same ages, but during the flying-bomb and rocket attacks their rate was slightly less than that of women. This contrast is explicable by the greater exposure to risk of men during air raids at night, owing the civil defence and other duties, than was the case during the flying-bomb and rocket attacks. The high rates among old people were probably due to the fact that comparatively few were evacuated, that they found it difficult to take shelter during raids, and to their greater need for hospital care when slightly injured.
Table 4: Number of civilians in London civil defence region killed by enemy action 1939–4511
Table 5: Number of civilians in Great Britain injured by enemy action 1939–45
Admitted to hospital (in most cases seriously injured)12
Treated at first-aid posts and mobile first-air units (estimated that one-fifth of these were sent to hospital)13
|Northern Ireland (1941–2)||678||1,793|
Table 6: Number of civilians in London civil defence region injured by enemy action 1939–45
|Admitted to hospital (in most cases seriously injured)||Slightly injured|