United States Army in World War II: China–Burma–India Theater

Stillwell’s Command Problems

by Charles F. Romanus and Riley Sunderland

. . . to Those Who Served

Table of Contents

Foreword

Preface

Part One: Plans and Preparations for the North Burma Campaign, October–December 1943

Chapter 1: The Last Preparations

Combined Chiefs Order a North Burma Campaign – Improving the Lines of Communications – The B-29 Project Approved – Chennault’s Operations – Chennault’s Proposals for 1944 – Building an East China Army – The Allied Command Structure in North Burma – The Chinese Forces – The American Force – The Kachin Rangers – The Battleground – Planning the North Burma Campaign – The Campaign Begins – Summary

Chapter 2: SEXTANT: The Watershed

Drafting SEAC’s Proposals – The United States Prepares for the SEXTANT Conference – The Chinese Prepare for SEXTANT – Presenting CHAMPION at Cairo – Trying To Reach Agreement – Over the Watershed: The Changed Attitude Toward China – Stilwell’s Search for Guidance – SEAC Tries To Salvage Burma Operations – A Changing U.S. Attitude – Summary

Chapter 3: The India-Based Air Effort

Command and Administration of the Air Forces – The Japanese Air Effort in Burma – Support of Ground Forces – Strategic Bombing – Air Supply – Allocation of Transport Aircraft – Administrative Problems – Techniques – Problems of Air Supply – The B-29 Command Problem – Logistical Problems of the B-29’s – Summary

Part Two: The North Burma Campaign, December 1943–August 1944

Chapter 4: Breaking the Stalemate in North Burma

The Chiangs Visit Their Troops – Yupbang Ga – The Opponents Shape Their Plans – Enveloping the Japanese Left Flank – The Capture of Taihpa Ga – Clearing the Taro Plain – The Allies Reorganize for the Next Effort – Logistical Support – Planning To Force a Decision – U.S. Infantry for the Second Phase – The Operation Begins – GALAHAD’s Fight at Walawbum – The “Big Squeeze Play” – Summary

Chapter 5: The Burma Campaign in the Balance

The SEXTANT Decisions Challenged – The Japanese Create More Command Problems – Mountbatten and Stilwell Meet – The Chiefs of Staff Reject CULVERIN – The Japanese Attack Forces Hump Diversions – Inkangahtawng: An Attempt That Failed – The Japanese Delay the 1st Battalion, 5307th – Delay at Jambu Bum – The Siege of Nhpum Ga – Air Supply Problem at Imphal – The Chindits Go Back to Burma – The Question of Myitkyina – Summary

Chapter 6: The Drive for Myitkyina

The QUARTERBACK Calls an END RUN – The 22nd Division and the Drive on Kamaing – The 38th Division: The Generalissimo and Stilwell – Turning Tanaka’s Flank – The 112th Regiment’s Stand at the Seton Block – Defeat of the 18th Division – Stilwell and the Chindits – The March to Myitkyina – MERCHANT OF VENICE! – The First Attempts To Take the Town – Japanese Build-up at Myitkyina – Command Problems at Myitkyina – The Attacks of Mid-June 1944 – Changes in Command – Hacking Out Small Gains – The Last Days – Summary

Chapter 7: Logistics and Administration

The Headquarters Reorganized – SOS Problems – Negotiations – Clearing the Port of Calcutta – Railway Problems – Military Railway Service Begins Its Work – Changes in Operating Procedure – Operations Under Military Railway Service – Physical Improvements on the Railway – A British Appraisal – Attempts To Use Indian River Transport – Pipelines in India – Supply Problems in India – New Agreements on Local Procurement – Housekeeping Problems – Chinese Lend-Lease – Medical Problems in the Rear Area – Logistical Problems in China – Summary

Part Three: Command Problems in China Theater

Chapter 8: Decisions to Attack

“Money Is the Root of All Our Trouble” – American Military Observers in North China – SEAC and Stilwell Obtain Pressure on Chiang – The Generalissimo Warns of Trouble – The President Demands Action – The Chinese Decide To Cross the Salween – Chennault Renews His Warnings – Operation ICHIGO – East China’s Defenders on the Eve of ICHIGO – Initial Reactions to ICHIGO – The East China Army Written Off – Summary

Chapter 9: The Chinese Take the Offensive

Battleground Above the Clouds: The Salween Front – The Chinese Plan for the Salween Campaign – The American Contribution – Beginning the Offensive – Pushing Through Ma-mien Pass – Clearing Ta-tang-tzu Pass, 11 May-12 June 1944 – Securing the Huei-jen Bridge Area, 11 May-14 June 1944 – Driving the Japanese Rear Guards From the Shweli Valley – The Southern Flank, 11 May-30 June 1944 – 71st Army and the Fight for Lung-ling, 28 May-15 July 1944 – Summary

Chapter 10: Facing the Command Problem

Stilwell’s Mission Laid Aside – Stilwell Called to China – Chennault Given 10,000 Tons – The Japanese Drive Rolls on in East China – Vice-President Wallace Suggests Stilwell’s Recall – Stilwell Nominated for Command – The Generalissimo Agrees “in Principle” – The Ledo Road Project Reduced – Slow Progress Across the Salween – The Battle for Sung Shan – Summary

Chapter 11: The China Crisis of 1944

The Defense of Heng-yang – Japanese Successes and Chinese Politics – The East China Crisis Grows – The Hurley-Nelson Mission – Washington Plans To End Stilwell’s Lend-Lease Powers – The Talks Begin – American Proposals, 12-13 September 1944 – Stilwell and the Question of the Communists’ Role – Crisis in the East, Crisis in the West – “I Do Not Seek the Job” – The President Replies – Summary

Chapter 12: The End of CBI Theater

The Note Delivered – The Generalissimo’s Wrath – Deadlock – End of the Deadlock – The Generalissimo Places the Blame – Waiting for the Decision – The President Ends CBI Theater – Conclusion

Bibliographical Note

Index

Charts

1. Stilwell in the CBI Chain of Command, December 1943-June 1944

2. Organization of U.S. Forces, China, Burma and India: November 1943-April 1944

3. Chih Hui Pu

4. Japanese Organization and Dispositions, November 1943

5. Tonnage Shipped From India to China by Air, 1944

6. Schematic Order of Battle of the Chinese Expeditionary Force

7. Tonnage Forwarded by USAF SOS CBI Advance Section to North Burma, January 1944-May 1945

8. Organization of the China Expeditionary Army, 15 September 1944

Tables

1. Tonnages Shipped to Burma Over Burma-Siam Railway, November 1943-August 1945

2. Average Daily Traffic at Terminals of Principal Branch Lines of Japanese-Operated Railways in Burma: January 1943-August 1945

3. Tonnage Delivered to Northern Combat Area Command by Air: April 1943-March 1945

4. Strength of U.S. Army Forces in the China–Burma–India Theater: January-September 1944

5. Fourteenth Air Force Aircraft Inventory by Type of Aircraft: March 1943-December 1944

Maps

1. India-China Communications System, October 1943-October 1944

2. The Battleground

3. ALBACORE Plan, 8 August 1943

4. Entering the Hukawng Valley, October 1943

5. Disposition of Forces, 1 December 1943

6. Operations in Northern Hukawng Valley, January 1944

7. Advance to Walawbum, 23 February-4 March 1944

8. Fight at Walawbum, 4-8 March 1944

9. Japanese Attack on Arakan Front, 4-7 February 1944

10. Japanese Offensive on Imphal Front, March-April 1944

11. Inkangahtawng, 12-23 March 1944

12. Shaduzup and Nhpum Ga, 24-29 March 1944

13. Mogaung Valley, 1 April-27 May 1944

14. Mogaung Valley, 28 May-26 June 1944

15. Advance to Myitkyina, 28 April-17 May 1944

16. Myitkyina, 18 May-End of July 1944

17. Situation in China, 15 March 1944

18. ICHIGO Plan

19. The Salween Campaign, 11 May-30 June 1944

Illustrations

The Kweilin Infantry Training Center – A Squad of Kachin Rangers – Cairo Conference – Chiang Kai-shek at Ramgarh – Bombing of Bridges – Kickers Prepare to Drop Supplies – Packing Supplies for Airdrop – Parachute-Covered Foxhole – Attack on Yupbang Ga – Japanese Fifteenth Army Commander and Staff* – General Stilwell and General Sun – Drainage Culverts – Pipeline Crossing a Stream – General Stilwell and General Merrill – A Chinese Cook – Troops of Merrill’s Marauders – Damaged M3A3 Tanks – Troops of the Chinese 22nd Division – A British Antiaircraft Unit – Japanese Defensive Positions – Allied Casualties at Myitkyina Airfield – Japanese Trenches – Artillery in Action at Myitkyina – General Stilwell and Colonel Hunter – The King George Dock Area – Railroad Operations in India – Supplies in Open Storage in India – Bridges Across the Yellow River – Gen. Wei Li-huang – An American Liaison Officer – American Engineers on the Burma Road – Chinese Troops Cross the Salween – Footbridge Across the Salween – Air-Supply Drops – Chinese 2nd Army Artillerymen – The Sung Shan Mountain Area – Evacuation of Kweilin – Vice-President Wallace – Chinese Infantrymen Rest on Lai-feng Shan – The Walled City of Teng-chung – Chinese Troops on Kung Lung-po Peak – Field Marshal Shunroku Hata* – Gen. Yasuji Okamura* – Chungking Conference – General Stilwell Entertains at Luncheon

The illustrations are from Department of Defense files, except those marked with *, which are Japanese photographs.

United States Army in World War II

Kent Roberts Greenfield, General Editor

Advisory Committee (As of 1 June 1954)

James P. Baxter, President, Williams College

Maj. Gen. Elwyn D. Post, Army Field Forces

Gordon A. Craig, Princeton University

Brig. Gen. Verdi B. Barnes, Army War College

Elmer Ellis, University of Missouri

Brig. Gen. C. E. Beauchamp, Command and General Staff College

William T. Hutchinson, University of Chicago

Brig. Gen. Leonard J. Greeley, Industrial College of the Armed Forces

Charles H. Taylor, Harvard University

Col. Thomas D. Stamps, United States Military Academy

Office of the Chief of Military History

Maj. Gen. Albert C. Smith, Chief*

Chief Historian, Kent Roberts Greenfield

Chief, War Histories Division, Col. G. G. O’Connor

Chief, Editorial and Publication Division, Lt. Col. T. E. Bennett

Chief, Editorial Branch, Joseph R. Friedman

Chief, Cartographic Branch, Wsevolod Aglaimoff

Chief, Photographic Branch, Maj. Arthur T. Lawry

* Maj. Gen. Orlando Ward was succeeded by General Smith on 1 February 1953.